Top 10 Roofing Companies in Madison, WI
Most homeowners aren’t looking to become roofing experts. When they’re searching for a roofing company, they want someone who will do good work, give them a fair idea of what the project will cost, and leave them with a roof they can feel good about.
Madison has no shortage of roofing contractors, which is helpful when you need options but can also make the choice harder. A small roof repair isn’t the same project as replacing an entire roof, and commercial roofing comes with its own set of requirements. It helps to know what different local companies actually offer before you start comparing estimates.
To make that process a little easier, we’ve put together 10 roofing companies serving the Madison area. This isn’t a strict ranking of who’s “best.” Instead, it’s a look at some of the local contractors homeowners and businesses can consider.
1. South Central Wisconsin Roofing
Of course, we’re going to put ourselves at number one. Here’s what we think Madison-area homeowners should know about us:
South Central Wisconsin Roofing has been serving Wisconsin homeowners and businesses since 1971, starting in Portage and growing our service area to include Madison, Dane County, Baraboo, Wisconsin Dells, and surrounding communities. A lot of our business has come through referrals and repeat customers, and we’re proud to have team members who have been with us for many years.
We handle residential and commercial roofing projects, including asphalt shingles, metal roofing, flat and rubber roofing, roof repair, replacement, storm damage, and new construction. On the commercial side, we work with systems such as TPO and EPDM and offer roof coatings that can be a practical option for some existing roofs that don’t need a full replacement.
Roofing isn’t the only exterior work we do. We also provide siding, insulation, windows, gutters, soffits, and fascia, so homeowners can coordinate several parts of an exterior project with one local contractor. We’re licensed in Wisconsin, an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, and Mule-Hide Certified, and we offer free, detailed estimates with straightforward recommendations. We also pay close attention to the details that can affect a roof’s performance, including ventilation, flashing, materials, and cleanup.
2. Maly Roofing Inc
Maly Roofing Inc. has been serving Madison since 1988, with residential and commercial roofing among its main services. The company handles asphalt shingles and ice dam repairs for residential properties, along with commercial systems such as TPO, EPDM, PVC, SBS modified bitumen, ballasted, and standing-seam roofing.
One of its more specialized offerings is green roof installation and rooftop pavers for flat-roof applications. Maly’s local project portfolio includes work at LaBahn Arena, Madison Public Library, and Monona Terrace.
3. Tilsen Roofing Company
Tilsen Roofing Company has been serving Southern Wisconsin since 1953 and focuses exclusively on commercial roofing. Its services include new commercial roof installations, roof replacement, repair, maintenance, waterproofing, sheet metal, and roof design and inspections. The company has also worked on several notable Madison-area projects over the years, including the original Hilldale Mall, the former Madison General Hospital, and an addition to the Edgewater Hotel.
4. Legacy Exteriors
Legacy Exteriors has been serving Southern Wisconsin since 2005 and is a family-owned business led by owner Josh Gauwitz. Based in the Madison area, the company handles roofing along with other exterior projects, including siding, gutters, windows, decking, soffit and fascia, and four-season sunrooms.
Josh remains involved in the day-to-day business and individual projects, while the company works with manufacturers including GAF and Mastic. Legacy Exteriors is also a member of NARI and holds GAF Master Elite and Mastic Elite Contractor certifications.
5. Isthmus Roofing
Isthmus Roofing has more than 25 years of experience serving residential and commercial properties in the Madison area and throughout Wisconsin. Its services include roof installation, roof repair, new roof projects, commercial roofing, and storm damage restoration, along with siding and other exterior work.
The company works on everything from residential houses to apartment complexes and multi-family buildings, including EPDM flat roofing systems. Isthmus Roofing also offers free estimates and handles repairs involving issues such as leaks, shingles, and ventilation. The company is a GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed ShingleMaster contractor.
6. Tempel Roofing
Tempel Roofing serves South Central Wisconsin, including Madison and communities within roughly 50 miles of the city. The company provides residential and small commercial roofing services, including roof repair, roof leak repair, roof replacement, new roof installation, inspections, and maintenance. It works with materials such as architectural shingles, standing seam metal, and tile roofing.
Tempel also offers exterior services including siding, replacement windows, and gutter solutions.
7. Paramount Roofing
Paramount Roofing & Siding has been serving Madison and the surrounding area for more than 25 years. The company handles residential and commercial roofing, including asphalt shingles, metal roofing, standing seam systems, and EPDM rubber roofing. It also provides siding, replacement windows and doors, gutters, fascia, and other exterior services. Paramount serves communities across Dane County and nearby counties, including Cambridge and Columbia County, and says most residential roof replacements can be completed in one day, including tear-off and re-roofing.
8. Frey Construction
Frey Construction has been serving the Madison area since 1995 and focuses on complete roof replacements rather than repairs. The company installs asphalt shingles, including Class 3 and Class 4 impact-resistant options, 24-gauge steel roofing, Duro-Last PVC systems for flat and low-slope sections, and Tilcor stone-coated steel shingles. Frey also provides siding, windows, and other home improvement services. Every roofing project includes on-site supervision by a Frey employee or project manager, along with a 15-year workmanship warranty.
9. Synergy Steel Inc
With more than 40 years in commercial roofing, Synergy Steel Inc works with businesses, property managers, and developers in the Madison, Sun Prairie, and Waunakee areas. The company specializes in flat and metal roofing, installing systems such as TPO, EPDM, PVC, and metal.
Synergy Steel also handles commercial roof maintenance, leak repairs, storm damage, and roof restoration. For structurally sound roofs that are showing wear, its fluid-applied coating services can provide an alternative to full replacement.
10. Ridge Top Exteriors
Ridge Top Exteriors has been serving Madison for more than 20 years as a family-owned contractor. Its exterior services include roofing, siding, windows, gutters, and repairs, with roofing options such as shingles and flat roofing. The company installs Mastic vinyl siding, LP SmartSide, and James Hardie fiber cement, as well as Pella windows in vinyl, fiberglass, and wood. Ridge Top also provides hail damage inspections and serves homeowners throughout Dane County and surrounding communities.
Why Madison Homeowners Choose South Central Wisconsin Roofing
A roofing project is a significant investment, and we think homeowners should have enough information to make a decision without being pressured into one.
We provide detailed estimates, explain the work in plain language, provide quality craftsmanship, and use materials selected for Wisconsin’s weather conditions. Our crews also focus on the parts of the job that aren’t always obvious from the ground, including proper ventilation, flashing, deck condition, and cleanup.
If you’re comparing roofing companies in Madison, we’re happy to give you another estimate and let you decide whether we’re the right fit for your project.